In Panama's adversarial criminal justice system, the right to defense is one of the essential pillars for ensuring a fair and equitable process. Since the implementation of this system, replacing the traditional inquisitorial model, there has been a greater emphasis on protecting the fundamental rights of individuals accused of a crime, ensuring they have the opportunity to adequately defend themselves before the law.
What is the Right to Defense?
The right to defense is the set of procedural safeguards that an individual has to protect their rights when facing a criminal accusation. This right allows the defendant to have a fair trial, to be heard, to present evidence in their favor, and to be represented by an attorney. In Panama's adversarial criminal justice system, this right is reinforced by the incorporation of principles such as transparency, orality, and the swiftness of judicial proceedings.
Fundamental Principles of the Right to Defense
Presumption of Innocence: Every person is presumed innocent until proven guilty by a final judgment. This means that the accused must not be treated as guilty before the judicial process concludes.
Access to Legal Counsel: From the moment a person is accused of a crime, they have the right to be represented by an attorney, either of their choice or, if necessary, one appointed by the State. This representation is key to ensuring the defendant understands the process, can present an adequate defense, and safeguards their rights throughout the trial.
Right to Be Informed: The defendant has the right to be informed of the charges brought against them, as well as the evidence that exists in support of those charges. This enables them to effectively prepare their defense, understand the scope of the accusations, and determine the most suitable legal strategy for their case.
Active Participation in the Process: In the adversarial system, the accused has the right to actively participate in their trial. This includes the ability to challenge the evidence presented by the Public Prosecutor, request evidence in their favor, cross-examine witnesses, and present their own version of events.
Fair and Public Trial: The right to a fair and public trial is another core aspect of the defense in the adversarial system. Hearings are public, ensuring the transparency of the process and allowing society to observe its progress. Furthermore, the trial is conducted before an impartial judge who will evaluate the evidence objectively.
The Role of Defense Counsel
In Panama's adversarial criminal justice system, defense counsel plays a crucial role in protecting the defendant's rights. Their function is not only to represent the accused before the court but also to advise them from the outset, prepare an appropriate legal strategy, and ensure that all procedural safeguards are respected.
Defense attorneys are also responsible for ensuring that the process is equitable and that the defendant's fundamental rights are not violated, such as the right against self-incrimination, the right to privacy, and due process.
Challenges to the Right to Defense in Panama
While the adversarial criminal justice system has brought significant improvements to the administration of justice in Panama, there are still some challenges in the practice of the right to defense. These include:
Insufficient Resources: Although the system guarantees the appointment of public defenders for those unable to afford private counsel, in some cases, high caseloads and limited resources can affect the quality of the defense provided by public attorneys.
Shortened Deadlines: The efficiency of the adversarial system is a positive aspect, but it can also pose a challenge. The shorter deadlines for presenting evidence and preparing a defense may make it difficult to build a comprehensive defense, especially if the necessary information is not available from the start.
Resource Disparities: Although all defendants have the right to defense, the resources available to prepare a case can vary significantly between those who can afford private counsel and those who rely on public defenders. This disparity may impact the course and outcome of the trial.
Conclusion
The right to defense is an essential guarantee in Panama's adversarial criminal justice system, which seeks to balance the power of the State with the protection of individual rights. This system, grounded in transparency and equity, ensures that every person accused of a crime has the opportunity to defend themselves adequately and fairly.
As attorneys, it is our responsibility not only to understand these safeguards but also to apply them effectively to ensure that our clients receive robust and comprehensive defense, protecting their rights at every stage of the criminal process.
This article is not only an invitation to learn more about the right to defense but also a reminder of the importance of its effective application in achieving true justice in Panama.
Comments